- The Marketing Minds Newsletter by Aleric Heck
- Posts
- How to Build Communities That Are Actually Profitable & Successful
How to Build Communities That Are Actually Profitable & Successful
The 4 Types of Online Communities & Which One Will Transform Your Business
I just wrapped up an incredible podcast interview with Jordan Godbey, the mastermind behind some of the most profitable online communities for people like Ali Abdaal, Justin Welsh, and David Gerhardt.
And let me tell you - the insights he shared absolutely blew my mind! 🤯
As a Reminder, Our Goal with this Newsletter is to Give You the Highest Level of Value Possible. That's my Promise to you & I intend to Over-Deliver!
Here's a Sneak Peek at What's Inside This Email:
I'll reveal the #1 BIGGEST mistake people make with communities (and why it's killing their profits)
You'll discover the 4 different types of communities & exactly which one is right for YOUR business
You'll get the exact onboarding framework that reduces churn to almost zero
And I'll reveal the "First Moment of Value" principle that hooks members instantly
Alright, let's Dive In...
The Community Revolution: Why 2025 is THE Year to Launch Your Profitable Community
If you've been thinking about launching an online community but haven't pulled the trigger yet, I've got news for you — you're sitting on a goldmine and don't even know it!
But here's the thing... Most people are doing it completely WRONG.
Jordan dropped this truth bomb right at the beginning of our conversation:
"The community is NOT the offer — it's the vehicle to deliver the offer."
Let that sink in for a second... 🤔
Most creators think they can just say "Join my community for marketers, it's $99/month" and call it a day. But that's like saying "Buy my car, it has wheels!" - it completely misses the point!
The 4 Types of Communities
Jordan and his team have built almost 100 communities at this point, and they've discovered they ALL fall into one of these 4 categories:
1. Pure Communities ($10-100/month)
Low Price + Low Structure
Think Dave Gerhardt's Exit 5 - a community for B2B marketers with the tagline "because nobody goes to school for B2B marketing."
These are great if you have a MASSIVE audience, but beware - they require constant value-add to combat churn!
2. Masterminds ($1,000+/month)
High Price + Low Structure
These rely on peer connections with high-caliber members. You're paying for access to successful people who can open doors.
The challenge? It requires a leap of faith from members since outcomes aren't guaranteed.
3. Community-Powered Courses ($97-497)
Low Price + High Structure
Remember all those courses you bought but never finished? (Yeah, me too! 😅)
This model adds community support to traditional courses, dramatically increasing completion rates and value without jacking up the price.
4. Transformational Communities ($2,000-20,000)
High Price + High Structure
These are the GOLD STANDARD — cohort-based programs with crystal-clear outcomes like "grow from 6 to 7 figures" or "launch your first business."
Jordan's own $10,000 cohort sold out with just 5 spots because the promise was so specific: "Launch your paid community in 90 days with our frameworks."
The Counterintuitive Launch Strategy That Changes Everything
Here's where Jordan really blew my mind...
Most people think you need to start cheap and work your way up. WRONG!
Jordan recommends going HIGH-TICKET first, especially if you don't have a massive audience.
Why? Because you only need 5 people at $10,000 to make $50,000, versus needing 500 people at $100/month for the same revenue!
Plus, higher-ticket clients are more committed, get better results, and require less customer support overall. It's a total win-win-win!
This Edition of the Marketing Minds Newsletter is Sponsored by:
Meet your new assistant (who happens to be AI).
Skej is your new scheduling assistant. Whether it’s a coffee intro, a client check-in, or a last-minute reschedule, Skej is on it. Just CC Skej on your emails, and it takes care of everything:
Customize your assistant name, email, and personality
Easily manages time zones and locales
Works with Google, Outlook, Zoom, Slack, and Teams
Skej works 24/7 in over 100 languages
No apps to download or new tools to learn. You talk to Skej just like a real assistant, and Skej just… works! It’s like having a super-organized co-worker with you all day.
The "First Moment of Value" Framework That Hooks Members Instantly
This might be the most important lesson from the entire interview...
Jordan says engagement is actually a CHAIN of events, and if you break that chain early, you're done.
It starts with your marketing promise and continues through every single touchpoint. But here's the kicker — you need to engineer that "First Moment of Value" to happen as quickly as possible!
Instead of dumping new members into a "giant pool full of people and stuff" (Jordan's words, not mine! 😂), you need a structured onboarding that:
Welcomes them with a 2-3 minute video confirming they made the right decision
Shows them EXACTLY where to find what was promised in your marketing
Teaches them how to customize notifications so they only get what matters
Gets them to that first WIN within their first hour inside
The Churn-Killing Secret Nobody Talks About
Want to know the #1 way to reduce churn? Stop charging monthly!
Jordan shared that if your transformation takes 3-6 months, charging monthly is like asking "Do you still want to be here?" every 30 days. That's exhausting for everyone!
Instead, align your billing with your transformation timeline:
3-month transformations = Quarterly billing
6-month programs = Semi-annual billing
Year-long journeys = Annual billing only
You're not just reducing churn — you're creating committed members who are focused on results, not renewal decisions!
The AI Revolution Coming to Communities
We wrapped up talking about how AI is transforming communities & leading the charge with AI agents that can:
Answer member questions while you sleep
Point people to specific lessons or resources
Identify disengaged members automatically
Suggest engagement strategies based on data
Jordan even loaded his entire course into their AI agent, and now it provides instant, accurate support 24/7.
Watch or Listen to the Full Episode Now!
I've only scratched the surface of what Jordan shared in our 45-minute deep dive. Want to hear about:
His framework for surveying members to prevent invisible disengagement
The exact Circle workflows that automate engagement
How to transition from a "dead" community to a thriving one
Why he accidentally built his first course the WRONG way (and what it taught him)
OR Watch the Episode on YouTube: https://youtu.be/w-36856R0W4
Trust me, this is 45 minutes that could literally transform your business model!
Watch The Full Video on YouTube:
Complimentary Video Marketing Strategy Call!
Are you looking to Scale your Business with Video Marketing?
I want to invite you to a 1-1 Strategy call with my Team to map out a YouTube Ads & Video Marketing Strategy specifically for your Business!
This is a 45-minute call where we’ll dive into your Business, your Goals & map out a Custom Strategy to help you Achieve them through YouTube!
Fill out the Quick Booking form to Schedule your Strategy Call.
More Value Coming Next Friday!
Stay Tuned for More Great Value & Content Coming your Way!
Here’s a Sneak Peak at What’s Coming Next:
More Free Trainings & Resources — In your Inbox!
Real Case Studies & Examples of the Marketing Funnels that Scaled Coaching Businesses past 7 & 8 Figures
The REAL on-the-ground insights into what’s going on in the Online Marketing & Coaching/Consulting/High-Ticket Industry (Based on our Insights working with Thousands of Clients)
The Latest YouTube Ad & Marketing Strategies as we Discover Them - So that you’re Always on the Cutting Edge
Guest Articles, Videos & Podcasts from the Top Marketing Minds of Today — Stay tuned for some exciting announcements around this ;-)
And a LOT More…
I’m serious when I say I want this to be The Most Valuable Newsletter You’re Subscribed to — Look out for us in your Inbox Every Friday!
I’ll see you in the next one!
To Your Success,
- Aleric Heck | Founder & CEO of AdOutreach
How Did You Like This Week's Newsletter?Your Feedback helps us Improve the Marketing Minds Newsletter! |